PROVEN IN AND OUT OF THE COURTROOM

Group photo of attorneys from law firm Blish & Cavanagh, LLP

Are you liable for what others say on your platform?

On Behalf of | Jul 21, 2025 | Uncategorized

Many media companies face challenges because of the comments people post on their platforms. It is tough when, despite your best efforts in responsible reporting, others misuse your brand’s voice. You work hard to deliver accurate news, but sometimes user comments can lead to legal headaches. What can you do when this happens?

What the law says about online defamation?

US law has specific rules about defamation, which is harming someone’s reputation through false statements. The key question is whether you, as the platform owner, are responsible for defamatory comments others post. You are not liable if you simply provide a space for comments. Federal law, specifically Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, protects you from being treated as the publisher of user-generated content. Here are key points about the act:

  • It does not protect you if you actively participate in creating or developing the defamatory content.
  • You are still responsible for content your employees or official representative’s post.
  • The law does not prevent all lawsuits, but it provides a strong defense in many cases.

Remember, while Section 230 offers protection, it is not a blank check to ignore problematic content on your platform.

How to handle content moderation

What steps can you take to manage comments and reduce your risk? Here are some practical strategies.

  • Have clear community guidelines: Outline what behavior and comments are acceptable on your platform.
  • Use moderation tools: Implement tools that allow you or your team to quickly remove offensive or defamatory comments.
  • Respond quickly to complaints: Have a system for users to report problematic content and address these reports promptly.
  • Be consistent: Apply your guidelines fairly to all users.

By taking these steps, you show that you are actively working to manage content and prevent defamation.

What happens when someone protests a comment?

When a comment sparks outrage, it is important to act carefully. First, assess whether the comment violates your community guidelines or is potentially defamatory. If it is, remove it. Engage with your audience by acknowledging their concerns and explaining your content moderation process. However, avoid getting into lengthy debates about specific comments. Remember, your due diligence in fact-checking and having clear policies can protect you legally.

Staying ahead of the curve

So, are you liable for what others say on your platform? You are not, thanks to Section 230, but you need to be proactive in managing content. Working closely with an attorney ensures you stay compliant with the law. Legal support helps you navigate the court and legal system, allowing you to focus on your mission: pursuing the truth.